Accidents happen every day. However, the consequences can be far more severe when those accidents involve a motorcycle. That’s why understanding motorcycle accident laws is critical, whether you’re a rider or a car driver. Motorcycle accident laws differ from those for cars in some crucial ways, and these distinctions can significantly impact who’s held responsible and the compensation a rider might receive. These cases often involve accident injuries due to the lack of protection for motorcycle riders compared to those in enclosed vehicles.
Understanding the Complexities of Motorcycle Accident Laws
Motorcycle accident laws involve more than knowing the rules of the road. They also involve understanding insurance coverage, legal rights, and the challenges unique to motorcycle accidents. This includes dealing with biases against motorcyclists.
For instance, motorcyclists are overrepresented in traffic fatalities even though they make up a smaller percentage of vehicles on the road, which can feed into the misconception that they’re always reckless.
Motorcycle Helmet Laws and Your Accident Claim
One of the most significant legal distinctions between cars and motorcycles revolves around helmet use. Although most states have helmet laws to some degree, variations significantly impact motorcycle accident cases.
Twenty-nine states and Washington, D.C., require all riders to wear helmets. However, nineteen states only mandate helmet use for younger riders, typically under 18 or 21. In these states, adult riders with adequate medical insurance and the use of eye protections can ride without a helmet. This leads to interesting legal questions when an accident occurs.
For instance, some insurance companies might attempt to deny a claim based on not wearing a helmet in a state where it’s not mandated but recommended by safety groups like the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). The failure to use a helmet leading a an enhanced injury can be considered comparative fault on the motorcycle rider as contributing to their own injuries. Something to think about.
Motorcycle Insurance and No-Fault States
Motorcycle accident laws also become tricky when it comes to insurance, especially in “no-fault” states. In these states, your own insurance typically covers medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of who is at fault in an accident.
However, a unique issue arises with motorcycles in no-fault states like Florida. In Florida, a “motor vehicle” is defined as having four or more wheels for insurance purposes. This means motorcycles are exempt from the “no-fault” coverage law requiring Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits of $10,000.00 to be maintained as mandated for Florida motor vehicles, and an injured rider must usually claim/file a lawsuit against the adverse party involved for direct compensation and coverage of his/her medical expenses, present and future, as applicable. This directly affects the legal process, potentially making it more complex and lengthy than car accidents within those same no-fault states. A motorcycle rider may maintain certain coverages with automobile insurers, but typically, motorcycle coverages are prohibitively expensive and not within the budget of many riders…
Proving Negligence in a Motorcycle Accident
Just like in any traffic accident, proving negligence is key in a motorcycle accident claim. This requires demonstrating that the at-fault party had a duty of care and breached that duty, which directly caused the accident, and resulted in damages such as injuries.
Challenges for motorcyclists often include fighting biases against them and dealing with common excuses from drivers. It’s common to hear statements like, “I didn’t see the motorcycle,” or accusations that the biker was speeding or weaving between lanes. Evidence gathering becomes especially crucial in these situations.
This includes securing the police report, eyewitness statements, photos or video evidence of the accident scene, and potentially expert opinions from accident reconstruction specialists. Because motorcyclists are inherently more vulnerable on the road, accidents involving factors like potholes, road debris, or poorly maintained roads can significantly impact the case.
Additional Legal Considerations
Beyond helmets and insurance, motorcycle accidents have a range of legal aspects unique to them. Several things are especially important for motorcyclists to be aware of.
Lane Splitting Laws
Lane splitting, which is the act of a motorcycle riding in between lanes of stopped or slow-moving traffic, is another area with varying legality. Some states, like California, explicitly permit it with guidelines, while others strictly prohibit it. Even in states where it is allowed, adhering to lane-splitting laws is vital if an accident occurs during the maneuver.
Product Liability and Motorcycle Defects
In cases involving a defect with the motorcycle itself, product liability law may come into play. Holding the manufacturer accountable might require demonstrating that a design flaw or manufacturing error was what caused the accident or worsened injuries. The existence of recalls for specific motorcycle makes or models can become compelling evidence in such situations.
Comparative Negligence Rules
The concept of “comparative negligence” is essential. Many states apply this rule where if a rider is found partially at fault for the accident, their compensation can be reduced proportionally. For example, a rider considered 20% at fault in a case with $10,000 in damages might only receive $8,000.
Certain states adhere to “contributory negligence,” which is stricter. Under this principle, if the injured rider is deemed even slightly responsible (1% or more), they might be completely barred from receiving compensation.
Recent Tort Reform in Florida now modifies its comparative fault system to one that only permits recovery if a person is determined to be 50% or less at fault for an incident. If a person is held 51% or more at fault for an incident, then recovery through a claim is barred and they must file a lawsuit and present evidence of liability to a jury arguing for less fault than was assessed by the insurance company adjusting their claim. This is a rocky road to travel riddled with uncertainties…
FAQs About Motorcycle Accident Laws
Are motorcycle accidents no fault in Florida?
No, Florida’s no-fault law does not apply to motorcycle accidents. Although Florida is a “no-fault” car insurance state, meaning drivers have Personal Injury Protection (PIP) that covers them regardless of fault, this rule does not extend to motorcycle accidents. Injured riders in Florida typically have to file a claim directly against the at-fault party for injuries and medical expenses as motorcyclists do not fall under the requirements of the Florida “No Fault Law.” They are not required to maintain financial responsibility in the event of a crash.
Are most motorcycle accidents the biker’s fault?
Despite common biases, most motorcycle accidents are not solely the biker’s fault. Studies show that car drivers often violate the right of way in motorcycle collisions. These violations include failing to yield, improper lane changes, and left turns in front of oncoming motorcycles. Many times, accidents occur simply because motorcycles are difficult for motorists to see.
How much are most motorcycle accident settlements?
The average settlement amount for motorcycle accidents varies drastically depending on numerous factors. These factors include the severity of injuries, who’s found at fault, applicable insurance coverage, and the skill of involved legal counsel. Some settlements might only cover medical expenses, while others include lost wages, pain and suffering, future medical care, and punitive damages. While a simple case might settle for tens of thousands, a severe injury case can reach millions.
What to do if there is a motorcycle accident?
If you’re involved in a motorcycle accident:
-
Make sure to prioritize your safety and the safety of others. Seek medical attention promptly, even for seemingly minor injuries. This is crucial for your well-being and creates important documentation for a potential personal injury lawsuit.
-
Contact the police immediately and make sure to obtain a copy of the police report when available. The report often includes critical information about the accident and involved parties, including a narrative from the investigating officer. This becomes a valuable resource in building your case later.
-
Gather information at the scene, such as photos, contact details of witnesses, and information from the other driver involved.
-
Notify your insurance company promptly. Be cautious about what you disclose to the insurance adjusters representing the other parties involved. You should seek legal representation from an experienced attorney specializing in motorcycle accident law to handle communication with insurers, gather necessary evidence, and negotiate effectively for your best interests.
Conclusion
Motorcycle accident laws often involve complex insurance issues, the risk of biased perceptions, and challenges unique to motorcycles. Because motorcycles lack the physical protection of passenger cars, riders are more likely to experience catastrophic injuries in even seemingly minor crashes. With higher stakes, seeking guidance from a qualified attorney well-versed in motorcycle accident laws is absolutely vital.