Praying for those affected by Hurricanes Helene and Milton.

Navigating Car Insurance Claim Denial: A Guide for Car Owners

Dealing with the aftermath of a car accident is stressful enough, but it’s even more frustrating when your car insurance claim is denied. You paid your premiums believing your car insurance would be there when you needed it most. Now, you’re left wondering what went wrong and what you can do to get your claim approved.

This guide will cover some common reasons for a denied car insurance claim. We’ll discuss what you can do to fight back against wrongful denials. Plus, we’ll provide some tips to help prevent your claim from being denied in the first place.

Table of Contents:

Why Do Insurance Companies Deny Claims?

Insurance companies are businesses with a bottom line to protect. They aren’t in the habit of freely handing out large sums of money. While they are legally obligated to process claims in good faith, this doesn’t mean they won’t look for loopholes or try to minimize payouts.

Understanding the reasons behind claim denials can help you navigate this tricky landscape. Insurance companies may use bad faith practices to get out of paying you what you deserve.

Common Reasons for Car Insurance Claim Denial

While each car insurance claim denial is unique, many fall into several common categories:

Policy Exclusions and Limitations

Always carefully review your policy to know exactly what is and isn’t covered. For example, your policy may have coverage limits, or policy limits, on how much the insurance company will pay for property damage liability in an accident. You might find that certain types of accidents, damages, or injuries aren’t included in your plan or require additional coverage.  Many coverages are optional, are not required, and are thus not included in your policy. If you do not pay for it then you do not receive it.  

Missed Deadlines / Improper Reporting Procedures / Untimely Repairs

Failing to report the accident promptly to both the police (if required) and your insurance company can give them grounds to deny a claim. Always adhere to the notification timelines and procedures laid out in your policy.  It is important to give timely notice of a claim as you could prejudice the insurance company’s ability to investigate.  Failure to pay your premiums when due can result in your insurance being canceled and any payments made refunded to you.  If your vehicle has been damaged you cannot make any repairs if you intend to file a claim with your insurance or the insurance of another without first allowing them the opportunity to inspect, photograph and/or otherwise evaluate the damages caused and being claimed.

Insufficient Evidence of Fault or Damages

Your insurer must be convinced that the other party was at fault and that the claimed damages are legitimate. The law requires you to prove the other party was at fault to receive compensation for your accident losses.

Inadequate evidence, like blurry photos, no photos, a lack of independent witnesses, no surveillance, or inconsistencies in your account, can weaken your case and lead to denial. Consider these things ahead of time and document everything carefully. Your claim denial letter should state the exact reason why your claim was denied.

Pre-existing Conditions Complicating Injury Claims

If you’re claiming compensation for injuries, insurance adjusters may argue that a pre-existing medical condition is to blame rather than the accident. Providing detailed medical records and obtaining expert medical opinions can help strengthen your position and overcome this hurdle.

This will support the claim that the accident, not your previous condition, caused the current injuries. If the insurance company denies your claim, you may need to seek compensation in court.

Disputes Over Liability

Insurance adjusters will thoroughly investigate who was at fault in the accident. If there’s any disagreement over who was responsible or if both parties share some blame, your claim might be denied or reduced accordingly.

Working with a knowledgeable personal injury lawyer can help navigate this complex area. They will build a compelling case proving fault and the other party’s liability in the accident. This increases your chances of securing a fair settlement.

Suspected Insurance Fraud

Insurance companies have systems in place to detect potential fraudulent activity. If your claim raises any red flags—like no visible property damage, inflated damage claims, inconsistent stories, or suspicious medical treatment/bills—it could be denied based on suspicion of fraud.  Insurance Fraud is a Felony in Florida carrying monetary penalties and punishable with an incarceration period of over 1 year.

Material Misrepresentation

Insurance companies can raise this as a defense if you may have made incorrect/false statements at the time you applied for the insurance policy when you completed the application process.  You have a duty to provide accurate responses in your application.  If the insurance company determines the answer was wrong and they would have charged a higher premium had they been informed of / provided with accurate information of this fact then they have a right to cancel your policy and refund your premiums to date.  An example would be failure to list residents of your household, where you intend to garage your vehicles, or even your marital status.  If you receive a check in the mail with a cancellation letter DO NOT tender the check without first consulting a lawyer.  The insurance company may be wrong and we can defend this.  Once you tender that check you waive your rights to fight back.

Mistake

Insurance companies employ adjusters and attorneys who are human and make mistakes.  This could lead to a denial due to an error in their investigation.  MOst times, when you clear up the error it will satisfy their investigation and coverage will be afforded and the denial reversed in part or full.

What Can I Do If My Claim Is Denied?

Facing a car insurance claim denial isn’t the end of the road. If your car insurance company denies your claim, there are steps you can take to get the coverage your policy provides. Take these steps to try and get the decision reversed:

  1. Stay Calm and Understand the Denial

Receive the denial letter in writing and carefully review the reasons for the denial of the car insurance claim. Often, the explanation will highlight specific areas of concern or missing information that must be addressed.

Understanding the basis for the denial helps you plan your next move effectively. An insurance company denies claims for many reasons, so it’s important to understand why they denied yours.  It is best to consult an attorney.

2. Gather Strong Evidence

Comb through everything you’ve documented about the accident. Supplement it with additional evidence that might strengthen your claim, such as photos and videos of the scene, repair estimates, medical records and bills, police reports, and witness testimonies.

Your objective is to present a comprehensive and indisputable account of what happened, supporting your need for compensation. This will help you dispute their decision and give you leverage when filing a claim.  It is best to consult an attorney.

3.  File an Appeal With Your Insurer

Most insurers offer a multi-tiered appeal process, allowing denied claims to be reevaluated by different adjusters or departments. Your appeal letter must be well-structured, persuasive, and address the specific issues highlighted in the denial.

Remember to include any supporting documents and new evidence gathered during this stage. You will need to know the process for filing a claim in your state.  It is best to consult an attorney.

4.  Seek External Mediation or Legal Action

Suppose your appeal with the insurer proves unsuccessful. You might want to consider involving a third party lawyer to mediate the dispute. Mediation can facilitate a dialogue and lead to an agreement.  It is best to consult an attorney.

5.  Alternatively, consult an attorney specializing in insurance denials and even bad-faith insurance claims to discuss pursuing legal action if you believe your denial was unjustified. Filing a lawsuit can sometimes be the final resort in holding the insurer accountable. An injury lawyer can also help you recover medical expenses.

Minimize Your Risk of a Car Insurance Claim Denial

Being prepared is crucial in the unfortunate event of an accident:

  1. Know Your Policy: Regularly review your coverage. Ensure it aligns with your needs. Update it as your circumstances change.

  2. Meticulous Record-Keeping: Maintain well-organized files of your policy documents, payment receipts, and any accident-related information.

  3. Prompt Accident Reporting: Report the accident immediately. Follow any required procedures outlined by your insurer. Don’t delay in seeking medical attention.

  4. Honest and Accurate Information: When filing a claim, provide complete and truthful details. This builds trust and minimizes complications.

  5. Seek Professional Assistance: Consulting a lawyer, especially after a serious accident, can ensure you understand your rights and options fully. They can handle communication, negotiation, and legal processes while advocating for your best interests.

If your car insurance claim is denied, it’s not necessarily the end of the road. Researching some common reasons behind these denials in Florida helps you navigate and understand this situation better. If a company denies your claim, your state’s insurance department is a great resource for information.

Conclusion

A car insurance claim denial can be disheartening, but it’s not an insurmountable hurdle. Knowing your rights and following these proactive measures gives you the best chance of securing the compensation you deserve. Being prepared and proactive can help make the process smoother and protect your interests should you need to file a car insurance claim.

Have a Personal Injury Case? Contact Attorney Michael Appel Today

When you need a personal injury law firm in Miami, FL, that actively seeks compensation for you and your affected loved ones, turn to our personal injury law firm. Call (786) 800-3491 to book an appointment with Attorney Michael Appel, PLC.

Connect with Us

Check out our social pages or our reviews page for updates on what we have going on!

Contact Us

  • Attorney Michael Appel, PLC.
  • 9100 S. Dadeland Blvd. Suite 1500 Miami FL 33156
  • Sunset Office Park - 9370 SW 72nd St Suite A255 Miami, FL 33173
  • Monday - Friday: 9:00am - 6:00pm
Scroll to Top